Comparison of Sallen-Key and State variable topology for a Linkwitz-Riley cross-over network.
The most common general purpose cross-over filter today is the 4.order Linkwitz-Riley filter.
This can be implemented in different ways.
The 2 most common are compared.
Fig.1: Sallen-Key cross-over filter.
This filter uses 4 OP-AMPs and has a total of 16 components to determine the cross-over frequency.
To obtain identical component values for all components, 0.5*RF can be 2 resistors in parallel and 0.5*CF can be 2 capacitors in series. 20 components in total.
The cross-over frequency is: Fx = 1 / ( 2 * π * √0.5 * RF * CF ).
It is possible to design this filter with all components of identical value by adding a gain of 1.59 to each of the amplifiers.
The cross-over frequency is then: Fx = 1 / ( 2 * π * RF * CF ). .
Fig.2: State variable cross-over filter.
This filter is described in detail in ref. .
This filter uses 5 OP-AMPs and has a total of 8 components to determine the cross-over frequency. All frequency determining components are of the same value.
A continuously variable cross-over (for experimental purposes) can be built be replacing the 4 RF with a 4-gang potmeter.
The cross-over frequency is: Fx = 1 / ( 2 * π * RF * CF ).
|Simulation||Unity gain Sallen-Key filter||Unity gain state variable filter|
|Summation error, 5% capacitors, 1% resistors||-1.25/+1 dB||±0.4 dB|
|Summation error, 1% capacitors, 1% resistors||±0.35 dB||±0.4 dB|
|Input impedance variation||47 : 1||1.2 : 1|
|Summed output noise, NE5532 OP-AMPs||-116 dBu||-103 dBu|
|Summed output noise, OPA2134 OP-AMPs||-110 dBu||-97 dBu|
|Summed output noise, TL072 OP-AMPs||-103 dBu||-91 dBu|
Table 1 shows that the worst case summation error for the Sallen-key filter is 1.25 dB. This will be much less when the components are from the same batch/tape (the reason to use 4 extra components to obtain identical values).
The state variable filter is less sensitive to its source impedance than the Sallen-Key filter.
The Sallen-Key filter must be driven from a low impedance source.
The state variable filter is 13 dB more noisy than the Sallen-Key filter. The reason is that the summation amplifier in the state variable filter has a gain of 16 dB.
|||Texas Instruments: Analysis of the Sallen-Key Architecture.|
|||Dennis A. Bohn: A Fourth-order state variable filter for Linkwitz-Riley active crossover designs.|
This web-page, including but not limited to all text, drawings and photos, is the intellectual property of Poul Petersen, and is Copyright ©.
Reproduction or re-publication by any means whatsoever is strictly prohibited under International Copyright laws.
The author grants the reader the right to use this information for personal use only.
Any commercial use is prohibited without express written authorization from Poul Petersen.
The information is provided on an "as-is" basis and is believed to be correct, however any use of the information is your own responsibility.
This web-site may contain links to web-sites outside Poul Petersen domain ( www.poulpetersen.dk ).
Poul Petersen has no control over and assumes no responsibility for the content of any web-site outside Poul Petersen own domain.
Poul Petersen notes index
Poul Petersen diy index
|Copyright © Poul Petersen 2019. Last update: 20191029.||Valid HTML!|